Prevention-based approaches to social policy: The case of early childhood development


Share / Export Citation / Email / Print / Text size:

Evidence Base

Australia and New Zealand School of Government

Subject: Management


eISSN: 1838-9422





Volume / Issue / page

Related articles

VOLUME 2012 , ISSUE 2 (August 2012) > List of articles

  • |

Prevention-based approaches to social policy: The case of early childhood development

Alan Tapper / John Phillimore / Alan Tapper / John Phillimore

Citation Information : Evidence Base. Volume 2012, Issue 2, Pages 1-20, DOI:

License : (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)

Published Online: 26-December-2016



This article reviews the Australian evidence concerning interventions in early childhood aimed at promoting children’s psychological well-being and preventing social and psychological dysfunction in later life. Two kinds of research are surveyed. One is the Australian social science literature that has emerged in the last twenty years from five major research programs. The other is the evaluation studies that, more recently, have assessed the effectiveness of various early childhood preventive interventions. Together these studies provide an evidentiary platform for reviewing current policy in this field. A full analysis of ‘what works’ would need to include relevant international evidence, which is outside the scope of this article. However, the Australian evidence does support the current policy focus on good parenting programs, while also suggesting that a number of other factors matter in promoting children’s well-being.

Content not available PDF Share



  1. Allen, G 2011a. Early Intervention: The Next Steps, An Independent Report to Her Majesty’s Government, HM Government, London.
  2. Allen, G 2011b. Early Intervention: Small Investment, Massive Savings, The Second Independent Report to Her Majesty’s Government, HM Government, London.
  3. Amato, PR 1987. Children in Australian Families: The Growth of Competence, Prentice Hall, Sydney.
  4. Aos, S, Lee, S, Drake, E, Pennucci, A, Klima, T, Miller, M, Anderson, L, Mayfield, J, and Burley, M 2011. Return on Investment: Evidence-based Options to Improve Statewide Outcomes, Document No. 11-07-1201, Olympia: Washington State Institute for Public Policy.
  5. Banks, G 2010. Advancing Australia’s ‘Human Capital Agenda’, The fourth Ian Little Lecture, Melbourne, 13 April, available at:
  6. Baxter, J, Weston, R, and Qu, L 2011. Family structure, co-parental relationship quality, post- separation paternal involvement and children’s emotional well-being, Journal of Family Studies, 17(2): 86–109.
  7. Bayer, J, Hiscock, H, Scalzo, K, Mathers, M, McDonald, M, Morris, A, Birdseye, J and  Wake, M 2009. Systematic review of preventive interventions for children’s mental health: what would work in Australian contexts? Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 43: 695–710.
  8. Bayer, J, Hiscock, H, Okoumunne, OC, Scalzo, K and Wake, M 2010. Three-year-old outcomes of a brief universal parenting intervention to prevent behaviour problems: randomised controlled trial, Archives of Disease in Childhood, 95: 187–92.
  9. Bor, W, Najman, JM, Andersen, MJ, O’Callaghan, MJ, Williams, GM and Behrens, BC 1997. The relationship between low family income and psychological disturbance in young children: an Australian longitudinal study, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 31(5): 664–75.
  10. Bor, W, McGee, TR and Fagan, AA 2004. Early risk factors for adolescent antisocial behaviour: an Australian longitudinal study, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 38(5): 365–72.
  11. Bowen, S, Zwi, AB, Sainsbury, P and Whitehead, M 2009. Killer facts, politics and other influences: what evidence triggered early childhood intervention policies in Australia? Evidence and Policy, 5(1): 5–32.
  12. COAG [Council of Australian Governments] 2009a. Investing in the Early Years – A National Early Childhood Development Strategy, Council of Australian Governments, Canberra.
  13. COAG [Council of Australian Governments] 2009b. National Partnership Agreement on Early Childhood Education, Council of Australian Governments, Canberra.
  14. Dawe, S and Harnett, PH 2007. Improving family functioning in methadone maintained families:  results from a randomised controlled trial, Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 32: 381–90.
  15. de Graaf, I, Speetjens, P, Smit, F, de Wolff, M and Tavecchio, L 2008. Effectiveness of the Triple P Positive Parenting Program on behavioral problems in children: a meta-analysis, Behavior Modification, 32(5): 714–35.
  16. Edwards, B and Bromfield, L 2009. Neighbourhood influences on young children’s conduct problems and pro-social behaviour: evidence from an Australian national sample, Children and Youth Services Review, 31: 317–24.
  17. Edwards, B, Wise, S, Gray, M, Hayes, A, Katz, I, Misson, S, Patulny, R, and Muir, K 2009. The Stronger Families in Australia (SFIA) Study of the Impact of Communities for Children: National Evaluation of the Stronger Families and Communities Strategy – Final report. National Evaluation Consortium for the Department of Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs, Canberra.
  18. Edwards, B, Gray, M, Wise, S, Hayes, A, Katz, I, Muir, K, Patulny, R 2011. Early impacts of Communities for Children on children and families: findings from a quasi-experimental cohort study, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 65(10): 909–14.
  19. Evans, MDR, Kelley, J and Wanner, RA 2001. Educational attainment of the children of divorce: Australia, 1940–90, Journal of Sociology, 37(3): 275–97.
  20. Freeman, R 2009. Recursive politics: prevention, modernity and social systems, Children and Society, 13(4): 232–41.
  21. Freiberg, K, Homel, R and Branch, S 2010. Circles of Care: the struggle to strengthen child developmental systems through the Pathways to Prevention Project, Family Matters, 84: 28–34.
  22. Garrett, P and Ellis, K 2012. Giving the most vulnerable Australians the best start in life, Joint Media Release, 7 May, .
  23. Harrison, L, Ungerer, J, Smith, J, Zubrick, S and Wise, S, with Press, F, Waniganayake, M and the LSAC Research Consortium 2009. Child care and early education in Australia: The Longitudinal Study of Australian Children (Social Policy Research Paper No. 40). Canberra: Department of Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs.
  24. Havighurst, SS, Wilson, KR, Harley, AE and Prior, MR 2009. Tuning in to Kids: an emotion-focused parenting program – initial findings from a community trial, Journal of Community Psychology, 37(8): 1008–23.
  25. Havighurst, SS, Wilson, KR, Harley, AE, Prior, MR and Kehoe, C 2010. Tuning in to Kids: improving emotion socialization practices in parents of preschool children – findings from a community trial, Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 51(12): 1342–50.
  26. Hayatbakhsh, MR, Najman, JM, Jamrozik, K, Mamun, AA, Williams, GM and Alati, R 2006. Changes in maternal marital status are associated with young adults cannabis use: evidence from a 21-year follow-up of a birth cohort, International Journal of Epidemiology, 35(3): 673–79.
  27. Head, B and Redmond, G 2011. Making prevention work in human services for children and youth, Australian Review of Public Affairs, 10(1): 5–22.
  28. Heckman, JJ 2006. Skill formation and the economics of investing in disadvantaged children, Science, 312: 1900–02.
  29. Heckman, JJ  and  Masterov, DV  2007. The  productivity  argument for  investing  in  young  children. Review of Agricultural Economics, 29(3): 446–93.
  30. Hemphill, SA and Littlefield, L 2001. Evaluation of a short-term group therapy program for children with behavior problems and their parents, Behaviour Research and Therapy, 39: 823–41.
  31. Hilferty, F, Mullan, K, van Gool, K, Chan, S, Eastman, C, Reeve, R, Haas, M, Griffiths, M and Katz, I 2010. The Evaluation of Brighter Futures, NSW Community Services’ Early Intervention Program, SPRC Report 13/10, prepared for Community Services, Department of Human Services, NSW.
  32. Hiscock, H, Bayer, JK, Price, A, Ukoumunne, OC, Rogers, S, Wake, M 2008. Universal parenting programme to prevent early childhood behavioural problems: cluster randomised trial, British Medical Journal, 336: 318–21.
  33. Homel, R and Freiberg, K. The Pathways to Prevention Project: implications for social policy in Australia, Griffith University. CDDB-8CCE33873CB29541
  34. Katz, I, Edwards, B, Gray, M, Wise, S, Hayes, A and Muir, K 2010. The national evaluation of the Communities for Children initiative, Family Matters, 84: 35–42.
  35. Kemp, L, Harris, E, McMahon, C, Matthey, S, Vimpani, G, Anderson, T, Schmied, V, Aslam, H, Zapart, S 2011. Child and family outcomes of a long-term nurse home visitation programme: a randomised controlled trial, Archives of Disease in Childhood, 96(6): 533–40.
  36. Kitzman, HJ, Olds, DL, Cole, RE, Hanks, CA, Anson, EA, Arcoleo-Sidora, KJ, Luckey, DW, Knudtson, MD, Henderson, CR Jr., Holmberg, JR 2010. Enduring effects of prenatal and infancy home visiting by nurses on children: follow-up of a randomized trial among children at age  12 years, Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 164(5): 412–18.
  37. Leech, M, Anderson, C and Mahoney, C 2007. Research-practice-policy intersections in the Pathways to Prevention project: Reflections on theory and experience. In France, A and Homel, R (eds.) Pathways and crime prevention: Theory, policy and practice. Willan Publishing, Cullompton, Devon, UK.
  38. Lexmond, J and Reeves, R 2009. Building Character. Demos, London.
  39. Liddell, M, Barnett, T, Roost, FD and McEachran J 2011. An Evaluation on the National Rollout of HIPPY. Final report to the Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations.
  40. Manning, M, Homel, R and Smith, C 2006. Economic evaluation of a community based early intervention program implemented in a disadvantaged urban area of Queensland, Economic Analysis and Policy, 36(1–2): 99–119.
  41. Manning, M, Homel R and Smith C 2010. A meta-analysis of the effects of early developmental prevention programs in at-risk populations on non-health outcomes in adolescence, Children and Youth Services Review, 32(4): 506–19.
  42. McGee, TR, Hayatbakhsh, MR, Bor, W, Cerruto, M, Dean, A, Alati, R, Mills, R, Williams, GM, O’Callaghan, M and Najman, JM 2011. Antisocial behaviour across the life course: an examination of the effects of early onset desistence and early onset persistent antisocial behaviour in adulthood, Australian Journal of Psychology, 63(1): 44–55.
  43. Mihalopoulos, C, Sanders, MR, Turner, KMT, Murphy-Brennan, M and Carter, R 2007. Does the  Triple P-Positive Parenting Program provide value for money? Australian and New Zealand  Journal of Psychiatry, 41: 239–46.
  44. Moore, TG 2008. Rethinking universal and targeted services. CCCH Working Paper 2. Parkville, Victoria: Centre for Community Child Health.
  45. Muir, K, Mullan, K, Powell, A, Flaxman, S, Thompson, D and Griffiths, M 2009. State of Australia’s Young People: A Report on the social, economic, health and family lives of young people. Report for Office for Youth, DEEWR, Social Policy Research Centre, University of New South Wales.
  46. Najman, JM, Behrens, BC, Andersen, MJ, Bor, W, O’Callaghan, MJ and Williams, GM 1997. Impact of family type and family quality on child behavior problems: a longitudinal study, Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 36(10): 1357–65.
  47. Najman, JM, Aird, RL, Bor, W, O’Callaghan, MJ, Williams, GM and Shuttlewood, GJ 2004. The generational transmission of socio-economic inequalities in child cognitive development and emotional health, Social Science and Medicine, 58(6): 1147–58.
  48. Najman, JM, Clavarino, A, McGee, TR, Bor, W, Williams, GM and Hayatbakhsh, MR 2010. Timing and chronicity of family poverty and development of unhealthy behaviors in children: a longitudinal study, Journal of Adolescent Health, 46(6): 538–44.
  49. Nicholson, JM, Berthelsen, D, Abad, V, Williams, K and Bradley, J 2008. Impact of music therapy to promote positive parenting and child development, Journal of Health Psychology, 13(2): 226–38.
  50. Nicholson, JM, Berthelsen, D, Williams, K and Abad, V 2010. National study of an early parenting intervention: implementation differences on parent and child outcomes, Prevention Science, 11(4): 360–70.
  51. Nowak, C and Heinrichs, N 2008. A comprehensive meta-analysis of Triple P-Positive Parenting Program using hierarchical linear modeling: effectiveness and moderating variables, Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review, 11(3): 114–44.
  52. Olds, DL, Eckenrode, J, Henderson, CR, Kitzman, H, Powers, J, Cole, R, Sidor, K, Morris, P, Pettitt, LM and Luckey, D. 1997 Long-term effects of home visitation on maternal life course and child abuse and neglect: fifteen-year follow-up of a randomized control trial, Journal of the American Medical Association, 278(8): 637–43.
  53. Olds, DL, Kitzman, H, Cole, R, Robinson, J, Sidora, K, Luckey, D, Henderson, C, Hanks, C, Bondy, J, Holmberg J 2004. Effects of nurse home visiting on maternal life-course and child development: age-six follow-up of a randomized trial, Pediatrics, 114: 1550–59.
  54. Price-Robertson, R, Smart, D and Bromfield, L 2010. Family is for life: connections  between childhood family experiences and well-being in early adulthood, Family Matters, 85: 7–17.
  55. Robinson, G, Zubrick, SR, Silburn, S, Tyler, W, Jones, Y, D’Aprano, A, McGuinness, K, Cubillo, C, Bell, M, and Stock, C 2009. ‘Let’s Start: Exploring Together. An early intervention program for Northern Territory children and families. Final evaluation report’, Darwin: School for Social and Policy Research, Institute of Advanced Studies, Charles Darwin University.
  56. Robinson, G, Tyler, W, Jones, Y, Silburn, S, and Zubrick, SR 2012. Context, diversity and engagement: early intervention with Australian Aboriginal families in urban and remote contexts, Children and Society, 26: 343–55.
  57. Robinson, M, Oddy, WH, Li, J, Kendall, GE, De Klerk, NH, Silburn, SR, Zubrick, ST, Newnham, JP, Stanley, FJ and Mattes, E 2008. Pre and postnatal influences on preschool mental health: a large- scale cohort study, Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 49(10): 1118–28.
  58. Ruschena, E, Prior, M, Sanson, A and Smart, D 2005. A longitudinal study of adolescent adjustment following family transitions, Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 46(4): 353–63.
  59. Sanders, MR, Turner, KMT and Markie-Dadds, C 2002. The development and dissemination of the Triple P-Positive Parenting Program: a multilevel, evidence-based system of parenting and family support, Prevention Science, 3(3): 173–89.
  60. Sanders, MR, Turner, KMT and Markie-Dadds, C 2003. Theoretical, Scientific and Clinical Foundations of the Triple P!Positive Parenting Program: A Population Approach to the Promotion of Parenting Competence. Parenting Research and Practice Monograph, No. 1. The Parenting and Family Support Centre, University of Queensland, .
  61. Sanders, MR 2012. Development, evaluation, and multinational dissemination of the Triple P-Positive Parenting Program, Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 8: 345–79.
  62. Sanson, A, Letcher, P, Smart, D, Prior, M, Toumbourou, JW, Oberklaid, F 2009. Associations between early childhood temperament clusters and later psychosocial adjustment, Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 55(1): 26–54.
  63. Sanson, A, Smart, D and Misson, S 2011a. Children’s socio-emotional, physical, and cognitive outcomes: do they share the same drivers? Australian Journal of Psychology, 63: 56–74.
  64. Sanson, AV, Havighurst, SS and Zubrick, SR 2011b. The science of prevention for children and youth, Australian Review of Public Affairs, 10(1): 79–93.
  65. Silburn, SR and Zubrick, SR 1996. The WA Child Health Survey: methodology and policy implications.  Paper  presented  at  the  Fifth  Australian  Family  Research  Conference,   Brisbane.
  66. Sawyer, MG, Kosky, RJ, Graetz, BW, Arney, F, Zubrick, SR and Baghurst, P 2000. The national survey of mental health and well-being: the child and adolescent component, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 34: 214–20.
  67. Smart, D 2007. Tailoring parenting to fit the child, Australian  Family Relationships Clearinghouse, No. 4. .
  68. Smart, D, Hayes, A, Sanson, A and Toumbourou, JW 2009. Mental health and well-being of Australian adolescents. In D. Bennett, S. Towns, E. Elliott and J. Merrick (eds) Challenges in adolescent health: An Australian perspective (pp. 49–60). Nova Science Publishers, New York.
  69. Wake, M, Sanson, A, Berthelsen, D, Hardy, P, Misson, S, Smith, K, Ungerer, J and the LSAC   Research Consortium 2008. How well are Australian infants and children aged 4 to 5 years doing? Findings from the Longitudinal Study of Australian Children wave 1, Social Policy Research Paper No. 36, Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
  70. Wise, S, da Silva, L, Webster, E and Sanson, A 2005. The Efficacy of Early Childhood Interventions. A report prepared for the Australian Government Department of Family and Community Services. Australian Institute of Family Studies, Melbourne. .
  71. Zubrick, SR, Silburn, SR, Garton, A, Burton, P, Dalby, R, Shepherd, C, Carlton, J, Lawrence, D 1995. Western Australian Child Health Survey: Developing Health and Well-being in the Nineties. Australian Bureau of Statistics. ABS Catalogue No. 4304.5.
  72. Zubrick, SR, Silburn, SR, Garton, A, Gurrin, L, Burton, P, Dalby, R, Shepherd, C, Carlton, J and Lawrence, D 1996. Western Australian Child Health Survey: Family and Community Health. Australian Bureau of Statistics. ABS Catalogue No. 4304.5.
  73. Zubrick, SR, Ward, KA, Silburn, SR, Lawrence, D, Williams, AA, Blair, E, Robertson, D and Sanders, MR 2005. Prevention of child behavior problems through universal implementation of a group behavioral family intervention, Prevention Science, 6(4): 287–304.
  74. Zubrick, S, Smith, G, Nicholson, J, Sanson, A, Jackiewicz, T and the LSAC Research Consortium 2008. Parenting and Families in Australia. Social Policy Research Paper 34. Department of Families, Housing, Communities and Indigenous Affairs, Canberra. .



  • |