The impact of welfare to work on parents and their children

Publications

Share / Export Citation / Email / Print / Text size:

Evidence Base

Australia and New Zealand School of Government

Subject: Management

GET ALERTS

eISSN: 1838-9422

DESCRIPTION

0
Reader(s)
0
Visit(s)
0
Comment(s)
0
Share(s)

SEARCH WITHIN CONTENT

FIND ARTICLE

Volume / Issue / page

Related articles

VOLUME 2015 , ISSUE 3 (September 2015) > List of articles

  • |

The impact of welfare to work on parents and their children

Michelle Brady * / Kay Cook

Citation Information : Evidence Base. VOLUME 2015 , ISSUE 3 , ISSN (Online) 1838-9422, DOI: 10.21307/eb-2015-003, September 2015 © 2105.© The Australia and New Zealand School of Government

License : (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)

Published Online: 27-February-2017

ARTICLE

ABSTRACT

When Welfare to Work activities for single parents were first introduced in the 2005 Commonwealth Budget, the primary claim was that these measures would increase individual wellbeing. A decade on, the veracity of this claim has yet to be comprehensively assessed. In this article, we systematically review the 41 Australian studies of income support recipients who were the primary carers of children, to examine the impacts of welfare-to-work on child and parent wellbeing. In line with the themes contained within these studies, we synthesized the findings related to three key areas of wellbeing: financial wellbeing; social connection and subjective wellbeing; and physical and psychological wellbeing. Academic research on the impact of Welfare to Work reforms on the wellbeing of single parents and their children presents an overwhelmingly negative picture whereby reforms have forced parents to participate in services that use ‘work-first’ and ‘one size fits all’, ‘blanket’ or ‘rigid’ approaches that do not help parents to meet their aspirations. Research also suggests that the reforms have decreased the financial wellbeing of single parents and their children, resulting in parents making the transition from welfare to work feeling less satisfied with their future security and standard of living, and higher poverty rates amongst the population of single parents with dependent children. However, there remain significant gaps in our understanding of how Welfare to Work affects parents and their children.

Content not available PDF Share

FIGURES & TABLES

REFERENCES

  1. ACOSS [Australian Council of Social Services] 2005. Welfare Reform: Participation Or Punishment? ACOSS Info 373. ACOSS, NSW, Australia 
  2. Alexander, M, Baxter, J, Hughes, J and Renda, J 2005. Evaluation of the Impact of Activity Requirements for Parenting Payment Customers on their Children Aged 13–15 Years, Australian Institute of Family Studies, Canberra 
  3. Australian Government 2005. Welfare to Work 10 May 2005 Budget Overview. Canberra, Australian Government 
  4. Australian Government: DEEWR [Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations] 2008. Welfare to Work Evaluation Report, Australian Government, Canberra, Australia 
  5. Australian Government: DEWR [Department of Employment and Workplace Relations]. 2005. Australians Working Together Report, Australian Government, Canberra, Australia 
  6. Barón, JD, Cobb-Clark, DA and Erkal, N 2008. Cultural transmission of work-welfare attitudes and the intergenerational correlation in welfare receipt. Available at SSRN 1319272 
  7. Blaxland, M 2013. Street-level Interpellation: How Government Addresses Mothers Claiming Income Support. Journal of Social Policy, 42(04): 783–797 
  8. Blaxland, M. 2009. Welfare to work activity agreements, or how to reduce mothers’ autonomy by requiring they do what they are already doing, Australian Social Policy Conference: An Inclusive Society? Practicalities and Possibilities, 8–10 July 2009 SPRC, UNSW 
  9. Bodsworth, E 2010. Making Work Pay and Making Income Support Work, Brotherhood of St Laurence, Victoria, Australia 
  10. Buddelmeyer, H, Freebairn, J and Kalb, G 2006. Evaluation of policy options to encourage welfare to work. Australian Economic Review, 39(3): 273–292 
  11. Butterworth, P 2003.The prevalence of mental disorders among income support recipients: an important issue for welfare reform. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, 27(4): 441–448 
  12. Butterworth, P, Fairweather, AK, Anstey, KJ and Windsor, TD 2006. Hopelessness, demoralization and suicidal behaviour: the backdrop to welfare reform in Australia. Australian and New Zealand journal of Psychiatry, 40(8): 648–656 
  13. Butterworth, P, Burgess, PM and Whiteford, H 2011. Examining welfare receipt and mental disorders after a decade of reform and prosperity: analysis of the 2007 National Survey of Mental Health and Wellbeing. The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 45(1): 54–62 
  14. Cai, L, Vu, H and Wilkins, R 2007. Disability support pension recipients: who gets off (and stays off) payments? Australian Economic Review, 40(1): 37–61 
  15. Cass, B and Brennan, D 2002. Communities of support or communities of surveillance and enforcement in welfare reform debates. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 37(3): 247–262 
  16. Commonwealth of Australia 2005. Budget Paper no. 2: Budget Measures 2005–06, Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra 
  17. Cook, K 2012. Single parents’ subjective wellbeing over the welfare to work transition. Social Policy and Society, 11(2): 143–155 
  18. Cook, K, Davis, E, Smyth, P and McKenzie, H 2009. The quality of life of single mothers making the transition from welfare to work. Women & Health, 49(6-7): 475–490 
  19. Cook, K and Noblet, A 2012. Job satisfaction and ‘welfare-to-work’: Is any job a good job for Australian single mothers? Australian Journal of Social Issues, 47(2): 203 
  20. Cook, K, Ward, B, McKenzie, H, Noblet, A and Bodsworth, E 2009. How welfare-to-work requirements impact on single parents' volunteer activities. Australian Journal on Volunteering, 14: 1–8 
  21. Dawkins, P 2001. The case for welfare reform as proposed by the McClure report. Australian Economic Review, 34(1): 86–99 
  22. Eardley, T, Saunders, P and Evans, C 2000. Community Attitudes Towards Unemployment Activity Testing and Mutual Obligation, SPRC Discussion Paper No. 107. SPRC, Sydney, Australia 
  23. Feeny, S, Ong, R, Spong, H and Wood, G 2011. The impact of housing assistance on the employment outcomes of labour market programme participants in Australia. Urban Studies, 49(4): 821–44 
  24. Ferguson, H 2013. What can the unemployed teach us about work? Continuum, 27(2): 311-322 
  25. Fok, YK, Jeon, S and Wilkins, R 2012. Does part-time employment help or hinder single mothers’ movements into full-time employment? Oxford Economic Papers, 65(2): 523–47 
  26. Government of Australia. Australians Working Together: Helping People to Move Forward, Parents: Questions and answers Australian Government viewed May/012015 
  27. Grahame, T and Marston, G 2012. Welfare-to-work Policies and the Experience of Employed Single Mothers on Income Support in Australia: Where are the Benefits? Australian Social Work, 75(1): 73–86 
  28. Greenberg, D, Deitch, V and Hamilton, G 2009. Welfare to Work Programs Benefits and Costs: A Synthesis of Research, MDRC, New York, New York 
  29. Gregory, RG, Klug, E and Thapa, PJ 2008. Cut‐offs, Knock‐ons and Welfare Payment Taper Changes: An Evaluation of the July 2000 Tax and Welfare Changes for Lone Mothers. Economic Record, 84(266): 291–309 
  30. Hamilton, G 2012. Improving Employment and Earnings for TANF Recipients, Temporary Assistance for Needy families Program, Synthesis Brief Series, Brief 06. Urban Institute, Washington DC 
  31. Hamilton, G 2000. Do Mandatory Welfare-to-Work Programs Affect the Well-being of Children? A Synthesis of Child Research Conducted as Part of the National Evaluation of Welfare-to-Work Strategies, MDRC, New York, New York 
  32. Harding, A, Vu, QN, Percival, R and Beer, G 2005a. The Distributional Impact of the Proposed Welfare-to-Work Reforms upon Sole Parents, Report to the National Foundation for Australian Women, Canberra, Australia 
  33. Harding, A, Vu, QN, Percival, R and Beer, G 2005b. Welfare-to-work reforms: impact on sole parents. Agenda, 12(3): 195-195–210 
  34. Harding, A, Vu, QN and Percival, R 2005c. Large income losses from Welfare to Work reforms. Developing Practice, 14: 13–15 
  35. Harding, A., Vu, Q.N., Percival, R and Beer, G 2005d. The distributional impact of the proposed Welfare-to-Work reforms upon sole parents and people with disabilities, 34th Conference of Economists, University of Melbourne 
  36. Harris, P 2000. Participation and the new welfare. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 35(4): 279–300 
  37. Henman, P 2002. Myths of welfare reform. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 37(1): 71–84 
  38. Henman, P and Perry, J 2002 Welfare dependency? A critical analysis of changes in welfare recipient numbers. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 37(3): 315–35 
  39. Kiely, KM and Butterworth, P 2013a. The contribution of financial hardship, socioeconomic position and physical health to mental health problems among welfare recipients. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, 37(6): 589–590 
  40. Kiely, KM and Butterworth, P 2013b. Social disadvantage and individual vulnerability: A longitudinal investigation of welfare receipt and mental health in Australia. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 47(7): 654–666 
  41. Kiely, KM and Butterworth, P 2014. Mental health selection and income support dynamics: multiple spell discrete-time survival analyses of welfare receipt. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 68(4): 349–355 
  42. Leigh, A, Wilkins, R and van Zijll de Jong, M 2008. Working Credits – A Low Cost Alternative to Universal Earned Income Tax Credits? Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research, Melbourne, Australia 
  43. McArthur, M, Thomson, L and Winkworth, G 2013. Jumping through hoops–the cost of compliance on sole parents. Child & Family Social Work, 18(2): 159–167 
  44. Newman, J 1999. The Challenge of Welfare Dependency in the 21st Century, FaCS Discussion Paper, Australian Government, Canberra 
  45. O'Connor, B 2001. The intellectual origins of ‘welfare dependency’. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 36(3): 221–36 
  46. Pearse, V. 2000. Parents Participation and Planning-The Parenting Payment Intervention Pilot, Family Matters, 2000 Australian Institute of Family Studies 
  47. Pech, J and Landt, J 2001. Work and welfare: the evolving role of income support. Family Matters, 58(Autumn): 23–27 
  48. Raymond, J 1987. Social Security Review. Bringing Up Children Alone: Policies for Sole Parents. Australian Government, Canberra 
  49. Saunders, P 2002a. Mutual obligation, participation and popularity: Social security reform in Australia. Journal of Social Policy, 31(01): 21–38 
  50. Saunders, P 2002b. Working for the dole: patterns of paid and volunteer work among income support recipients. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 37(4): 337–362 
  51. Saunders, P and Brown, J 2004. Explaining welfare to work transitions among the unemployed. Australian Journal of Labour Economics, 7(3): 395 
  52. Scott, EK, Edin, K, London, AS and Kissane, R 2001. Unstable Work, Unstable Income: Implications for Family Well-being in the Era of Time-Limited Welfare, The Next Generation Project, Working Paper No. 5. MDRC 
  53. Summerfield, T, Young, L, Harman, J and Flatau, P 2010a. Child support and welfare to work reforms: The economic consequences for single-parent families. Family Matters, 84: 68–78 
  54. The Social Research Centre 2005a. Customer and Community Attitudes to Working Age Participation Requirements, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations, Canberra 
  55. The Social Research Centre 2005b. Personal Adviser Evaluation Research - Customer Survey Wave 1, Research Report Final. The Social Research Group, Melbourne, Australia 
  56. The Social Research Centre 2005c. Personal Adviser Evaluation Research - Customer Survey Wave 2, Research Report Final. The Social Research Group, Melbourne, Australia 
  57. Tseng, YP, Vu, H and Wilkins, R 2008. Dynamic Properties of Income Support Receipt in Australia. Australian Economic Review, 41(1): 32–55 
  58. Walter, M 2002. Working their way out of poverty? Sole motherhood, work, welfare and material well-being. Journal of Sociology, 38(4): 361 
  59. Wilkins, R (ed.) 2013. Families, Incomes and Jobs, Volume 8 A Statistical Report on Waves 1 to 10 of the Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia Survey, Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research, Melbourne, Australia 
  60. Wilkins, R and Leigh, A 2012. Effects of Temporary In‐Work Benefits for Welfare Recipients: Examination of the Australian Working Credit Programme. Fiscal Studies, 33(3): 335–369 
  61. Wilson, S and Turnbull, N 2001. Wedge politics and welfare reform in Australia. Australian Journal of Politics & History, 47(3): 384–404 
  62. Wilson, K, Pech, J and Bates, K 1999. Parents, the Labour Force and Social Security, Policy Research Report No.2. Department of Family and Community Services, Canberra 
  63. Ziguras, S, Considine, M and Dufty, G 2003. Much Obliged: Disadvantaged Job Seekers' Experiences of the Mutual Obligation Regime. Brotherhood of St Laurence, Victoria, Australia. 

EXTRA FILES

COMMENTS

  • |